Book Review: Murder in Punch Lane by Jane Sullivan

 Murder in Punch Lane

by

Jane Sullivan

Publisher: Echo Publishing

Publication date: 2nd July 2024

Genre: Historical Fiction / Mystery

Pages: 368

RRP: AU$32.99 (paperback)

Source: courtesy of the publisher

 

Review: Murder in Punch Lane

Set in 19th Century Melbourne Murder in Punch Lane is a haunting murder mystery.

Inspired by the death in 1868 of actress Marie St Denis from a laudanum overdose Jane Sullivan writes a fictional 'what if' story; what if she was actually murdered?

 

Sullivan's writing is poetic and lyrical which justly suits the backdrop of the story being rehearsals of a Shakespearean play.

Thinking it is much more than the recorded cause of suicide, actress Lola Sanchez takes it upon herself  to investigate the death of her friend Marie. She enlists the help of journalist and magazine editor Magnus Scott.

 

I did enjoy the setting of a bohemian Melbourne with dark alleys and opium dens and also the melodramatics of the theatre rehearsals.

 

What I did struggle with was the characters, not one likeable one among them! Our female main character was a fatalist where I wanted a fighter and her offsider, like every man in this book, was a misogynist.

Crooked police and judges, allusions to actresses willingly sleeping with men to get parts and a gentleman's dinner where the women attend naked, it was more ick than gothic. 

 

I did love the writing, I had no clue who the murderer was, and there were plenty of suspects, plus the unexpected twist that really knocked me all contributed to my rating.

 

My rating 3.5 / 5 ⭐⭐⭐½